for (i=[1:10]) foo();

x = [
    for (i=[1:10]) i
];

x = [ <Enter>
<Tab> for (i=[1:10]) i <Enter>
]; <Enter>
hello <Enter>
world

x = [
    for (i=[1:10]) i
        ];
    hello
    world

x = [ <Enter>
<Tab> for (i=[1:10]) i <Enter>
<Backtab><Backtab>]; <Enter>
hello <Enter>
world

x = [
    for (i=[1:10]) i
];
    hello
    world

In 2019.05... The builtin editor gets some autoindent cases wrong.  (Yes, I use the built-in editor.) Case A: If you say for (i=[1:10]) foo(); it thinks the next line should be indented. Case B: If you say x = [ for (i=[1:10]) i ]; the first of all it'll try to indent the close-bracket line by two tab stops (one more than the for()), but then it will try to indent everything after that by one. That is, if I type: x = [ <Enter> <Tab> for (i=[1:10]) i <Enter> ]; <Enter> hello <Enter> world I get x = [ for (i=[1:10]) i ]; hello world Worse, if I type x = [ <Enter> <Tab> for (i=[1:10]) i <Enter> <Backtab><Backtab>]; <Enter> hello <Enter> world then I get x = [ for (i=[1:10]) i ]; hello world There are plenty of reasonable indentation styles, but I don't think this aligns with any of them. There's no urgency, but having discovered what looks like a bug I don't want to just drop it. Should I file a github issue?

On 16.03.20 02:37, Jordan Brown wrote: > Should I file a github issue? Nope, more issues with the same topic will not help. https://github.com/openscad/openscad/issues/2374 https://github.com/openscad/openscad/issues/1172 https://github.com/openscad/openscad/issues/1075 You could add the examples somewhere if they are not covered yet. I don't know if there's much of a chance to fix that though. Right now the editor is using the existing C++ indentation which causes the mismatch. Writing an OpenSCAD specific one is probably not an easy topic. It certainly would be nice to have of cause. ciao, Torsten.