Yep, have seen this one before.
If you make the assumption that, because the diameter of the hole isn't
stated, it isn't relevant, and the answer is therefore the same for
/any/ (hint, hint!) value, the solution using algebra is
straightforward. That assumption is correct, and so is the solution it
produces ... but you can't /prove/ that without calculus.
On 3/7/2022 3:30 AM, discuss-request@lists.openscad.org wrote:
On Sat, 2022-03-05 at 14:29 +0000, Raymond West wrote:
My understanding is that 'z fighting' indicates a situation where
there is some indecision as to which of the two or more of the
'fighting faces' should be used. In the physical world, it is the
same, you would not bore a hole exactly the same depth as the
workpiece, the result will not be what you may expect. I believe is
is good practice to avoid these sort of errors, even if the object
renders OK to an stl, say.
This brings to mind a puzzle I read when I was a teenager.
If you bore a hole through the center of a sphere such that the length
of the hole is 6", what is the volume of the remaining material?
Yep, have seen this one before.
If you make the assumption that, because the diameter of the hole isn't
stated, it isn't relevant, and the answer is therefore the same for
/any/ (hint, hint!) value, the solution using algebra is
straightforward. That assumption is correct, and so is the solution it
produces ... but you can't /prove/ that without calculus.
On 3/7/2022 3:30 AM, discuss-request@lists.openscad.org wrote:
>
> On Sat, 2022-03-05 at 14:29 +0000, Raymond West wrote:
>> My understanding is that 'z fighting' indicates a situation where
>> there is some indecision as to which of the two or more of the
>> 'fighting faces' should be used. In the physical world, it is the
>> same, you would not bore a hole exactly the same depth as the
>> workpiece, the result will not be what you may expect. I believe is
>> is good practice to avoid these sort of errors, even if the object
>> renders OK to an stl, say.
> This brings to mind a puzzle I read when I was a teenager.
>
> If you bore a hole through the center of a sphere such that the length
> of the hole is 6", what is the volume of the remaining material?